OK, so admittedly for the last 13 years I have told you my friends how great the Toyota product line is. It is a great product line, I will never tell you otherwise. I will however let you know I have made the switch to Honda, because I believe it is also a great product that is getting better! I want my customers , clients, and friends to have the BEST product on the market! I believe that in 2015-2016 model year Honda fills that bill.
Lets start with the all new Honda Pilot. In my opinion, the previous generation was ugly, boxy and just not modern enough. Honda has fixed that with the sleek new Pilot. Available in multiple grades starting with the LX, EX, EX-L , Touring and Touring Elite models I am sure there is a combination that will suit all your needs.
In this comparison I am going to compare to what I know. The Toyota Highlander. A redesign in 2014, it has sold well and dealers can not keep them on their lots . Like I said Toyota is a great product. The Highlander also comes in multiple trim levels, the LE, LE plus, XLE, Limited, and Limited Platinum. For this Comparison I am going to pit the top sellers against each other. The Toyota Highlander XLE and the Honda Pilot EX-L.
Head to head the warranties are identical . You get a 3yr 36000 mile Bumper to bumper warranty and a 5yr 60000 mile powertrain warranty. Toyota also gives you service at the Toyota dealership for 2 years or 25k miles. For a comparably equipped SUV you will spend about $1300 more MSRP to MSRP for the Highlander. The service has to come from somewhere right? Also, floor mats are standard on the Honda Pilot, you pay extra for them on the Highlander.
The Pilot produces 280hp at 6000rpm compare to 270hp at 6200 rpm on the Highlander and 262 lb/ft of torque at 4700 compared to 248 lb/ft on the Highlander. It takes less rpm to get more power out of the Pilot and that is reflected in the gas mileage too. Check this out The Pilot gets 18 city mpg/ 26 hwy mpg/ 21 combined compared to Highlander’s 18 city mpg/24hwy mpg/ 20 combined. Save on the price of the car and on actually using the car. Honda wins 2 out of 2, so far.
Safety is very important to me and Im assuming you as well. Toyota has the “star safety system” which consists of EBD, (electronic brake distribution) ABS, BA,(Brake Assist), VSC,(vehicle stability control) TRAC (traction control) . Honda has ALL these system PLUS the A.C.E. body structure. ACE (Advanced Compatibility Engineering) means that no matter what the front end of the vehicle collides with, Honda has engineered the front end to displace most energy away from the passengers compartment. Toyota offers no such body structure. Honda also puts a camera (lanewatch)on the passenger side that activates with the right turn signal giving the driver better visibility of anything on the right hand side. Toyota offers no such safety.
The Honda Pilot offers 3 cubic feet more of cargo space, and tons more room in the 3rd row. After selling both products I can without a doubt tell you an average adult CAN fit in 3rd row of this generation Pilot. The Highlander’s 3rd row is better for small children.
So there you have it, a head to head from a guy that has sold both. I think the 2015-16 Highlander is a great suv , and if you buy one you will be satisfied, unless you want an SUV that will give you more Power, Room, Safety features, save you gas and Cost you less. If you want one that does all that, come see me at Altoona Honda for a Pilot.